Buy or rent
How to compare buying and renting, what a break-even point measures, and the assumption that weighs most on the result.
People often say rent is money thrown out the window. But loan interest, notary fees, property tax and upkeep do not come back either. Renters and owners both pay for things that build nothing. The useful question is: which of the two builds more wealth, and how fast? The buy vs rent simulator applies this method to your numbers.
Compare wealth rather than payments
An instalment and a rent cannot be compared directly: part of the instalment repays capital, part pays the bank, and the rent pays for a roof. Instead, compare each side's net wealth, date by date: for the owner, the property's value minus what remains to repay, plus savings; for the renter, savings alone.
The renter keeps the money the buyer pays out on day one (down payment, acquisition costs, works). If it sits in a current account, buying nearly always wins. If it is invested, the comparison gets close. So the method gives the renter the same starting money, invested, and has whichever side spends less each month invest the difference.
Two trajectories, the same rules
Computed by Eventua on an example. Owner wealth (€) — solid line · Renter wealth (€) — dashed line
Show the data
| Year | Owner wealth (€) | Renter wealth (€) |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 15,000 € | 58,750 € |
| 1 | 25,078 € | 67,404 € |
| 2 | 35,458 € | 76,196 € |
| 3 | 46,150 € | 85,128 € |
| 4 | 57,164 € | 94,203 € |
| 5 | 68,511 € | 103,425 € |
| 6 | 80,201 € | 112,796 € |
| 7 | 92,247 € | 122,320 € |
| 8 | 104,660 € | 132,000 € |
| 9 | 117,452 € | 141,840 € |
| 10 | 130,636 € | 151,842 € |
| 11 | 144,225 € | 162,010 € |
| 12 | 158,232 € | 172,349 € |
| 13 | 172,672 € | 182,862 € |
| 14 | 187,559 € | 193,552 € |
| 15 | 202,908 € | 204,424 € |
| 16 | 218,735 € | 215,481 € |
| 17 | 235,055 € | 226,729 € |
| 18 | 251,887 € | 238,170 € |
| 19 | 269,246 € | 249,810 € |
| 20 | 287,151 € | 261,654 € |
Three rules keep the comparison fair and explain the shape of these curves. The renter starts ahead, because the owner paid to get in and the owner's wealth is counted net of what a resale would cost, from day one. The owner catches up, because every instalment amortizes a little more capital (amortization) and the property appreciates. Finally, no euro is counted twice: the day-one cash outlay is an expense for one side and starting capital for the other.
In depth : The break-even used is the last durable flip, not the first crossing, and it depends on the horizon.
Two curves can cross several times. An early crossing followed by a reversal does not count: the break-even used is the one after which the owner stays ahead through the end of the horizon. The break-even therefore depends on the horizon you look at: a flip durable over 30 years may not be over 15.
The assumption that weighs most
The result depends less on the known figures (price, rent, loan rate) than on the long-term assumptions, and one of them weighs more than all the others: property appreciation.
Computed by Eventua on an example. Break-even (years) — solid line
Show the data
| Appreciation (%/year) | Break-even (years) |
|---|---|
| 1 | 29.7 |
| 1.5 | 21.8 |
| 2 | 15.3 |
| 2.5 | 11.3 |
| 3 | 8.8 |
| 3.5 | 7.2 |
| 4 | 6 |
A buy-vs-rent result only makes sense with its appreciation assumption. Over the long run, French property prices have moved roughly with inflation, give or take a few tenths depending on the period, but nobody knows your city's trajectory over twenty years. A useful answer reads: "buying gets ahead beyond so many years if the property gains so much per year", together with what happens if it gains nothing.
In depth : Below a certain appreciation, there is no break-even at all within the horizon.
In the figure's example, below 1%/year of appreciation renting stays ahead over the whole 30 years: there is no flip point, and the curve stops. With a rent low relative to the price, buying may never catch up over a realistic life horizon.
Common mistakes
- Comparing instalment and rent. An instalment above the rent does not rule out buying, and the opposite does not justify it: it depends on the share that amortizes and on what the unspent money becomes.
- "I'll get my money back at resale." Not before the entry costs, the selling costs and the interest already paid are covered. In the first years the amortized capital is small, and an early resale often loses money.
- Forgetting the owner's costs. Property tax, co-ownership fees, upkeep, insurance: on the order of a few thousand euros a year, building no wealth and weighing on every year of the comparison.
- Reasoning on an unrealistic horizon. The break-even is often counted in decades; a job move, a separation or a new child often come sooner. The relevant horizon is how long you will actually keep this home, not the loan's term.
What the method does not measure
This method only counts money. The security of a home of your own, the freedom to move within a month, the right to knock down a wall, or the trouble of a difficult co-ownership do not appear in it. They often decide. The method gives the financial cost of the choice; the rest is up to you.
With your numbers
The buy vs rent simulator applies these rules to your situation, gives the break-even in years, and lets you test several assumptions side by side. If you already have a precise financing plan, the same comparison exists in the property purchase simulator, computed on your real schedule.
Sources
- Frais de notaire : de quoi s'agit-il ? (Service-Public.fr): the official breakdown of the entry costs counted on day one.
- Notaires de France: the property price statistics behind the appreciation orders of magnitude the simulator proposes.